Poor Lacey, and (poor?) Mowgli! I have two types of litter for the inmates here, and the vast majority prefer the clay litter over the clumping. I use clay for foster kittens rather than clumping which can cause bad things to the intestines if they eat it. It seems all the tiny ones go through a litter eating phase. I'd try three different types for each box, and see which one Mowgli prefers. I'm betting regular clay!