Hmm, well, personally I would not try to decide who to ride based on peoples judements on Pet Talk by looking at pictures of the two. There are facts that need to be taken in to consideration. How old are they? What are they like under the saddle? What are their vices? What are their strong points? Watch somebody else ride them and get an idea of what horse is more challenging and what horse is more green. That will truly help your riding experience.