Originally posted by BCBlondie
and my friend has told her parents several times to never ever give them treats unless they give them the treats and put them all in their crates.... but her dad didn't listen...
Oh, I can totally relate. It's so so dificult trying to raise a dog on your own when you live with your family. You tell them all the rules, but they don't listen.

I'm really sorry that your friend has to go through this. Maybe it would be better to find her a new home, maybe without other dogs? Or if your friend could convince her parents to let her work with Charlotte around other dogs? I'm sure the situation could be improved with lots of training and desensitizing.

I hope that Charlotte ends up in a great home, either way.