I have worked with Chubby on this. I did what cali said, and it worked very well. If any of the boys get excited when I want to give them a treat, I use this method.

dragondawg- Yes, I know that Chubby would not enjoy being tapped on the nose, and that is why I didn't use that method. He should be able to enjoy his treat time, in my opinion. Another reason I did not use this method is because I think he would get excited if I did this, and then just makes him more grabby.

Thanks for the ideas everyone! Now they can take treats nicely, and not bite momma's fingers off!