Well, her Mom (see other thread) says that she isn't declawed. So maybe he said it sarcastically. I'm anxious to know. She was walking around a construction site, so there could have been lots of stuff that would wear her paws down. I couldn't imagine it possible to create a bad declaw job. It's black and white...they amputate the claws. So I wouldn't think that some claws would be visible in a "bad declaw job"