Gee, Amberlee, my heart skipped a beat, becuase I never saw you post that Cassy had gone to the bridge! Then I reread and saw it was Sassy. Whew! Sassy sure was a cutie.

Big Mac is certainly not the good one in our house, because since I rearranged the furniture about a year ago and made the couch more accessible, he has shredded it. Also, everytime he goes outside to munch the grass he makes a mad dash for the door to make sure he throws up inside.

Pepper isn't the good one because she pees on the towels on the bathroom floor (at least she's not going on the rug - I can wash the towels!). Also, she's got claws like talons and her favorite place to plant them is in my leg. Besides, she sneaks into the attic through the laundry room.

Peaches isn't the good one because she taught Pepper how to sneak into the laundry room. Also, like Butter, her idea of playing involves teeth and claws - I guess it's a former stray thing!

So, the winner, with absolutely no faults, is:

COOKIE!!!!