I used to have a tabby that would play with anything you gave her. After she finished playing with her toys she would crawl under the living room rug and tuck away her toys. She would check to make sure no one was watching before she would walk "safely" away from the rug.

The cat we have now will only play with balls of aluminum foil and the rings that come off milk cartons. We have bought other toys for her that eventually go to the trash. Only the simple things satisfy Baby.