I used Fresh Step for years and then switched to Arm & Hammer for a while and now use Scoop Away. I don't really see a whole lot of difference. The Arm & Hammer did have a really nice smell but I think might have been a little more dusty. Actually now I go with what is available and what is on sale at this point. Jen, I think I will look for the Premium Scoopable Litter. There are 3 pet supply stores in my area and surely one of them must carry it. With your recommendation and at that price I don't think I could possibly go wrong.