Originally posted by carrie
I wouldn't worry about it unless you are having problems in the car or off lead - might be interesting to start insisting on a specific behaviour before letting him have the treat in the situations he usually takes it.....this is very interesting.....you could insist on it for two weeks, without fail, every time and then see if he will still accept it for free after that or if he then sits without being asked.
Carrie,

Smokey is a perfect companion in the car. He rides very well,
no problem. Not sure if I have this right, but you think if I
insisted on a sit/down, etc outside(every time) for two weeks
without fail then give him the treat & see if he'll take it anyway
for free(outside) or will he be more likely to sit/down on his own
without my asking him.? He does respond to hand signals as
well as my voice. (Unless the kitties run past to distract him)
I'd be willing to give this a try for sure. Thanks.