Welcome to PT Mike and Kristyn

I'm so sorry you lost Henry. RIP

I would go and meet Jen's fosters. She has some beautiful cats ready for adoption esp Annie .
http://petoftheday.com/talk/showthre...threadid=38529

Or look at Pet|Finder website.

My baby Tigs loves water and is very vocal and yet is a basic (lovable) tabby cat.

I would suggest you just wait and see which cat decides to come home with you.