I voted 2 b/c I also used to be a non- cat person.
Then I got my RB greyhound who opened my eyes to the love and spirit of all animals, and I was hooked.
I am at my limit right now with one dog and one cat, but I can see one more of something in my future eventually, and it would probably be kitty wise, b/c Keegan is kinda jealous when it comes to other dogs and her momma!