As to crate training...it isn't a punishment, rather, it is a tool. With Binx, I crated him for the first 3 days with me, until I had some time to see how he was, which happened on the Saturday and Sunday, 3 days after I got him. Binx doesn't 'need' to be crated. That is because of his breed, and prolly, his teeth. As a 4 month old puppy with teeth, I am sure I would have found his chewing a bit more destructive. Crating is a wonderful tool, when used right, as with most things.

Binx learned nothing his first day with me. Shoot, 6 months later, we are still working on some things....he he he...major things....