Alice:
http://catoftheday.com/archive/2001/May/16.html

On the Cat home page, instead of clicking on Pet Talk to get here, click on "Previous Cats", then click "by date" under "May" and then click on Frisky.

If someone "revives" an old thread by posting a reply to it, it comes back up to the top. Sometimes a newbie or someone who has been away from the board (vacation, busy schedules, etc.) is trolling through old posts, will reply, and lo and behold, and old thread looks new! This can really get confusing when it's one of the Cats of the Day that has been "revived". You're not the first to be confused by this.