Originally posted by Cinder & Smoke
Then again - if "Boxed Kitty" is screaming at the top of it's lungs " HALP! She's gonna kill me!" - this idea might have some draw-backs...
This might actually help though, depending on how close Eli was to the other cats. When Tubby screams bloody murder, Peanut just has to come see what's going on, and vice versa, so this might be a tactic to try. Although little Eli might be so scared that he won't be able to tell it's one of his housemates screaming and not another cat that he wants to steer clear of.

COME HOME ELI!!!