Hmm... well lets see

Toby: *sniff sniff* "whats that you got there?!! Lemme have a taste! " *chomp chomp* "This stuff is divine!! MORE!"

Lily: "I dunno about this new stuff ... let me have a taste I spose " *sniff sniff* "Nah....I might try it later"

So Toby loves it and Lily didn't even eat it ... maybe she was full. =/ She usually eats everything! I will try her again later. I gave them half a can each of Felidae canned food ... They LOVED that!