Logan I am so glad Lily does not have anything serious wrong that caused her weight gain. I do know that when I started my dogs on Innova from Eukuneuba (sp?) I decreased their portions dramatically because the food is so much more rich and filling. Cassie went from getting 1-1/2 cups per day when she was with her last owners, to only 3/4 cups a day. Graham went from getting 2 cups of Eukuneuba to 1-1/4 or less of Innova....and they both have pleanty of body fat still (especially Cassie). Hopefully the food thing will work out and the girls will lose those extra inches.