My girls will eat almost any packaged treat. I got a sample of the onceuponadog treat and they loved it. I thought the people were so nice to ship me the free sample that I ordered two boxes yesterday. they do have great nutrition. Also, I am a sucker for people who have good customer service skills. And these folks do. They even sent a Christmas card with a picture of their two boys and their two Rottweilers. I'm hooked.!!!