I'm one of the people who think's Clay is hott.
From the first audition I loved him. He's the best. (MY opinion)
Clay deserved to be AI because he had a GREAT voice, and could hit notes Ruben couldn't even dream of hitting. He also helps children with special needs. Now that's someone to look up to. He says that since celebrities have a large influence on how people act, and he wants to use that influence in the best way possible. He's a generous man. (I'm not saying Ruben's not, just making a point)
Who cares if he was a "dork" at first? I'm considered a "dork" at my school, so that means people can make fun of me if I tried to change my image? That comment bothered me a bit...it's not the first time I've heard it either.

Just wanted to add...can't miss a chance to talk about Clay.
Ah I'm getting WAY too involved in this...lol thank goodness I didn't write three pages.