Here's the puzzle:

"--e -ea--- a --- i- ---- a ------- --e- y-- a-e -----a-- i- --a- -e --e--'- a-- -- ---- --y."

~ A---y---- ~

The letters you have to choose from are:

BCDFGHJKLMNOPQRSTUVWXZ

*LabLoverKEB* (A)16
Karen (E)12
Fuzzy317 (I)4
delidog (Y)3