I LOVE having two dogs, but I have to say that three would probably be too much, and I would always be worrying about "who to love next". Plus, the expense of three would be more than I could handle. With two big dogs and two cats, all of which get regular veterinary care, in addition to the expenses related to accidents, problems, etc. I have all I can handle!! But....if the money weren't an issue, we'd throw another Golden Retriever into the mix in a skinny minute!! I think Honey and Lilly would handle it fine.