Here's the Puzzle:

"It --e--e-- -o-- --eat- a-- -el-- --e-e-t ta-ta-"

~-el -i--o-, --ile eati-- a -o- -i---it at -a--a--.


Letters to guess:

BCDFGHJKMNPQRSUVWXYZ

There are 3 O's
There are 3 L's
and I missed a T before, so Captain has gained 1 point...

Uabassoon has 18+12=30 points
Karen has 18 points
Captain has 8+3=11 points
Fuzzy317 has 6 points