Originally posted by wolf_Q

I was tempted to try the prong collar but then most everyone on here made me feel guilty for even thinking about it.
You know, there isn't anything wrong with the pronged collar. It protects both the dog and walker from any ill fated moves into traffic, towards any moving person/animal, makes walks enjoyable and even possible, for some doggies. It is supposed to be a deterrent. It does not puncture the skin (or it shouldn't!), and is much better than a dislocated shoulder, or a pup that gets hit by a car. It can also be utilized in training the pup to behave.

I don't intend to use one on Binx because he isn't a huge puller, yet. BUT, if I find I cannot walk him with safety for me, him,and the general public, I will go to a prong collar.

My sister resisted the prong for sometime. She now walks, with confidence, at the same time, her rottie and GSD.