We adopted Olivia in December too. Olivia, Noel and Basil all get along. Noah and Olivia on the other hand, DONT.

This week, Olivia gave Noah a cute on his tummy...that's why those two have Soft Paws.

Its sad when you want them to be friends. Maybe Emily just isn't cut out for another cat in the works. As long as they aren't unhappy, they'll just tolerate each other.