Here's the Puzzle:

If a -o-'s pra-ers -ere a-s-ere-, -o-es -o--- rai- from t-e s--.
~O-- Pro-er-

Letters left to guess:

BCDGHJKLNQUVWXYZ
There are 5 O's
There is 1 M

Primabella has 5+1=6 points
Randi has 16 points
Felicia'sMom has 6points
Karen has 4 points
FloppsyLadySally has 8+1=9 points
Miss Meow has 2 points
Fuzzy317 has 2 points
Luckies4me has 10 points