I agree too. Kito isn't much of a judge--he barks at my dad, who is the most dog friendly person I know. But Abbey is--she is nice to everyone, but both dogs hate our roommates girlfriend--and she hates them too. She hates all animals and pets, she thinks they are dirty, and they know she doesn't like them.
My friend had an American Bulldog that was her boyfriend's and she kept him while he was in the process of moving to Georgia. The dog had some food agression issues, but that's about it. When our one roommate Andy, was alone with him, he attacked him and bit him right in the back of his thigh--and he was a creep--so I believe Marley knew that. Her cat didn't like him at all either.