Now I think I should be getting guesses after this up-date, it's almost the whole puzzle:

It is a matter to gain the affection of a cat. He is a philosophical animal, tenacious of his o-n ha-its, fond of order and neatness, and disinclined to e-travagant sentiment. He -ill -e -our friend, if he finds -ou -orth- of friendship, -ut not -our slave.
~Theophile Gautier


Luckies4me~ 20 E's x2=40, 22 I's x2= 44, 6 U's x2=12, 7 D's=7, 3 G's=3, Total=106pts.

Randi~ 18 O's x2=36, 18 T's=18, 13 S's=13, 5 C's=5, 8 L's=8, Total=80pts.

Amberlee~ 19 A's x2=38, 9 R's=9, Total=49pts.

Primabella~ 18 N's=18pts.

Cincy'sMom~ 11 F's=11, 3 M's=3, 4 P's=4, Total=18pts.

Karen~ 10 H's=10pts.

Miss Meow~ 2 V's=2pts

Letters Left To Guess
B J K Q W X Y Z