There is 25 N, 12 M, 16 L, 15 G, 15 D

A man -al-ing across a -ield encountered a tiger.
He -led, the tiger chasing a-ter him.
Coming to a cli--, he caught hold o- a -ild -ine
and s-ung himsel- o-er the edge.
The tiger sni--ed at him -rom a-o-e.
Terri-ied, the man loo-ed do-n to -here, -ar -elo-,
another tiger had come, -aiting to eat him.
T-o mice, one -hite, one -lac-, little -- little
-egan to gna- a-a- at the -ine.
The man sa- a luscious stra--err- near him.
Gras-ing the -ine -ith one hand, he -luc-ed
the stra--err- -ith the other.
”Ho- s-eet it tasted!”

Letters left to guess:
B F J K P Q V W X Y Z

Score:
Nomilynn – E(56) + O(25) + T(41) + S(14) + C(11) + M(12) + G(15) = 255
Luckies4me – A(35) + I(32) + N(25) + L(16) + D(15) = 174
Amberlee – U(6) = 12
Miss Meow – R(23) + H(29) = 52