There is 41 T, 23 R, 14 S, 29 H, 11 C

A -a- -a--i-- across a -ie-- e-cou-tere- a ti-er.
He --e-, the ti-er chasi-- a-ter hi-.
Co-i-- to a c-i--, he cau-ht ho-- o- a -i-- -i-e
a-- s-u-- hi-se-- o-er the e--e.
The ti-er s-i--e- at hi- -ro- a-o-e.
Terri-ie-, the -a- -oo-e- -o-- to -here, -ar -e-o-,
a-other ti-er ha- co-e, -aiti-- to eat hi-.
T-o -ice, o-e -hite, o-e --ac-, -itt-e -- -itt-e
-e-a- to --a- a-a- at the -i-e.
The -a- sa- a -uscious stra--err- -ear hi-.
-ras-i-- the -i-e -ith o-e ha--, he --uc-e-
the stra--err- -ith the other.
”Ho- s-eet it taste-!”

Letters left to guess:
B D F G J K L M N P Q V W X Y Z

Score:
Nomilynn – E(56) + O(25) + T(41) + S(14) + C(11) = 228
Luckies4me – A(35) + I(32) = 134
Amberlee – U(6) = 12
Miss Meow – R(23) + H(29) = 52