Opinions on Blue Buffalo cat food

[emily_the_spoiled]

I haven't used the Wildness brand of Blue, but I have used the other (especially the turkey). Most of my guys like it, but the problem is that the pieces are very very tiny and my blind cats have a hard time finding it So I use the Simply Nourish brand of cat food (the PetSmart house brand of healthy food)

[Queen of Poop]

My cats wouldn't touch it and my vet did not recommend it. She said those "life bits" or whatever they're called are bits of raw food and the cat needs to eat alot of those as the rest of it's not very good. This may be her commentary to get me to use the vet prescription food instead so just putting it out there for whatever it's worth.

[snakemama]

I manage a pet feed store, and in my opinion it's WAY overpriced, and we get a TON of bags returned because neither dogs nor cats will eat the "Life Source Bits". We recommend, Innova Prime, Taste of the Wild, California Natural Grain Free, and (If you can find it, it's a new and quite small company) Tuscan Naturals. Also, oddly, Whole Foods grocery stores have teamed up with a company that makes a food called Nulo, which is AWESOME. US made and sourced, and just...fantastic formulas.

[katladyd]

My cats all LOVED it!!! Ming has urinary tract issues and any food but Wilderness and Solid Gold Indigo Moon causes blockages in him. Wilderness is the best food I have ever fed my cats. They all have glossy coats, lots of energy, and Ming thrives on it! It's expensive, but of much higher quality than Eukenuba or Pro Plan. Those two are CHOCK FULL OF GLUTENS! You get what you pay for. I'm far from rich, heck, I'm not even comfortable, but my boys deserve the best and they get it. I highly recommend this food!

[Pinot's Mom]

Princess Pinot has been on Blue for some time and thrives on it. She eats the Chicken flavor of the dry with a spoonful of the canned mixed in (spa select variety, seafood flavors only, thank you very much). I feel the ingredients are far superior to many other brands and, believe you me, she is PICKY! Never had an issue changing over from Science Diet. As far as the cost; if you break it down, it's not that much money. We actually use half the food we did previously; the protein content fills up more that the unnecessary ingredients in other foods.

[katladyd]

Yep. 5 lbs. of the good stuff lasts just as long, if not longer, than 10 lbs. of the cheaper stuff. I couldn't afford it otherwise. If you had a housefull like Gary, I can see it being too expensive, but with up to 3, it is very economical.

[smokey the elder]

Thanks for all your input. I'm most concerned about my two oldest cats (14+, exact ages unknown.) Spike and Moby will eat anything that doesn't eat them first, and the less said about Nutmeg, the better. How does one cat in a houseful get so overweight when all the others have good weights?