Puzzle #600! - Everybody come play!

[Killearn Kitties]

M please Karen.

[Karen]

- th-nk - ----d t-rn -nd ---- w-th -n-m--s, th-- -r- s- p----d -nd s---*--nt--n'd
- st-nd -nd ---k -t th-m -nd --ng.
Th-- d- n-t sw--t -nd --mp---n ----t th--r --nd-t--n,
Th-- d- n-t --- -w-k- -n th- d-rk -nd w--p --r th--r s-ns,
Th-- d- n-t m-k- m- s--k d-s--ss-ng th--r d-t- t- G-d,
N- -n- -s d-ss-t-s---d, n-t -n- -s d-m-nt-d w-th th- m-n-- -- -wn-ng th-ngs,
N-t -n- kn---s t- -n-th-r, n-r t- h-s k-nd th-t ----d th--s-nds -- ---rs -g-,
N- -n- -s r-sp--t---- -r -nh-pp- ---r th- wh--- --rth.
S- th-- sh-w th--r r---t--ns t- m- -nd - ----pt th-m,
Th-- -r-ng m- t-k-ns -- m-s---, th-- ---n-- th-m p---n-- -n th--r p-ss-ss--n.

W--t Wh-tm-n, S-ng -- M-s---



Felicia's Mom: R(18) D(26) = 44
mrspunkysmom: S(35) T(52) P(9)G (8) W(10) = 114
Randi: N(51) = 51
Pinot's Mom: H(31) = 31
Freckles: K(9) = 9
Killearn Kitties: M(14) = 14

Letters left to guess:
ABCEDFIJLOQUVWXYZ

[Freckles]

L, please

[Asiel]

U please

[Pinot's Mom]

F please!