Puzzle #598

[Killearn Kitties]

Can I have an R please Karen.

[Karen]

R was already guessed, KK, another letter? Sorry I didn't delete it from "letters available!"

[Killearn Kitties]

Oops! Silly me, should have noticed.

P please.

[Pinot's Mom]

'M' please!

[Karen]

S- m-ny -f --r -r--ms -t f-rst s--m -mp-ss--l-,
th-n th-y s--m -mpr----l-, -n- th-n, -h-n -- s-mm-n
th- --ll, th-y s--n ----m- -n---t--l-.

-hr-st-ph-r R----

Letters to guess:
ABCDEGIJKOQUVWXYZ

Felicia's Mom: N(8) Y(3) = 11
mrspunkysmom: T(8) L(5) F(2) = 15
Pinot's Mom: S(10) R(7) H(8) M(9) = 34
Killearn Kitties: P(3) = 3

[Pinot's Mom]

How about a 'w'?