I always check out this website before buying any products in dog training - http://bestselling-ebooks.com/dog-trainer-handbook/ (Sorry but I don`t want to advertise). My personal favourite is Dog Trainer Handbook because because helps me to train my dog very good. I am very happy now and I want to help everybody which have a dog and want to train him. Now, my dog listen all orders. Thanks and I think that this reply will help you.