I think you'll be able to get it now.

There are 5 "F"s, 3 "Y"s, 2 "C"s,

The first for-al dog show was held in Great -ritain at Newcastle(-)on(-)Tyne in eighteen fifty nine. Si-ty -reeds of dog were divided into two categories: -ointers and Setters.

Score:
aly (I, N, L) - 43 points
Daisy's Mom (E, Y) - 43 points
Iditarodfan (D, T, G, S) - 39 points
Fuzzy317 (O, U, W, V, C) - 28 points
Dixie Belle (A, H) - 20 points
sammi (R) - 9 points
Cinder & Smoke (F) - 5 points

The letters you have left to choose from:
B J K M P Q X Z