The puzzle is the title of a book and a paragraph from it.

H-- T- ---e --th a -a----at--- -at

A re-e-t --r-e- re-e--e- that --t -- e-er- 250 -e---e, 216 are -at ---e--, 54 are -at hater-, a-- the re-- are --t --t--- th-- -ear. -r-- the-e re---t- -e -a- -ee -h- --r-e-- -h-----'t -e ta-e- t-- -er------.

Catty1 E27=58
Pinot's Mom T19 = 19
Felicia's Mom A16 = 32
sana R14 = 14
mrspunkysmom H7 = 7
Letters to guess:

BCDFGIJKLMNOPQSUVWXYZ