Thanks for the good vibes everyone. My mom and I decided we wouldn't report it because we didn't want the guy (considering he does seem to be a responsible dog owner) to get in trouble... or anything bad happen to his dog. But if this is the first incident, I suppose the dog wouldn't. In Utah, I believe, it is only required to be turned over to authorities if it is a human. I think if an animal actually dies they have to, too. I am not sure about that though, so don't quote me.
With your thoughts on the issue, though, I'll talk to my mom about filling out a police report. It could've been a one time thing, but it might not be. Would I just call animal control to do that?

Quote Originally Posted by Alysser View Post

Just a question..could it may have been out of play? I am sure this seems like a ridiculous question but Pitties are powerful dogs. I just refuse to believe that Pitbulls are "wired wrong" like some people think, and I know of course you never believed that about them. I am just bringing up a possible suggestion. I know it's a long shot, but ya never know.
It certainly wasn't out of play. I know dogs can get pretty rough in play. This was a full on mauling.

I don't think pitties are "wired wrong" either, however, I think they are at higher chance of being aggressive. For one, they are often owned by irresponsible owners. The need a special owner because of their dominant personality, they're very strong dogs, and they have a high prey drive like mentioned.
It's sad though, because I was just talking to my brother about pitties the other day. He does believe not all, but many pitties are inherently aggressive and unpredictable. His last boxer was attacked by a Pit Bull, he was bit in the face by a Pit Bull, Springen was bit and hurt last year, and now Sam.
I know it may just be coincidence, and Pit bulls are able to do much more damage than other dogs when they get in a fight. I love Luna, my bf's pittie, to pieces. I just don't know.