Lily sure is a cutie!!

It sounds like your Lily is a little more stubborn than my Molli, but Molli has always been picky. She's always been slightly underweight, wouldn't eat half her food.

Someone at the pet store I get my grain-free food from recommended I just add a little water to her kibble and let it soak until it's nice and mushy. She LOVES eating now! I can't believe the difference, she's now almost over weight! lol

I feed Acana Grasslands. I also give them the occasional dehydrated raw with their kibble. Have you tried that? It's like the consistency of thick oatmeal. They love it.