I've taken cats, dogs and both to see Santa, but not at an open place like PetsMart. One of the local rescues does a fund raiser Photos with Santa, in a credit union. The place is closed, you have a set time, you bring your pets in from the car and only you, your pets, Santa, photographer and a few volunteers who are ready to help pose pets are present.
Freedom, What you described would be the ideal situation for a photo with Santa. IF it ever happens around here (and I doubt it), more than likely I would take Luke and Annie.
Bookmarks