Okay, there are 11 L's, 5 U's, and 2 G's.

The greatest pleasure o- a -og is that -ou -a- -a-e a -ool o- -oursel- -ith hi- a-- -ot
o-l- -ill he -ot s-ol- -ou, -ut he -ill -a-e a -ool o- hi-sel- too.

Score:
*BaSim* A(10) + I(6) + H(7) + U(5) = 49
Karen E(11) + T(10) = 32
Logan O(17) + P(1) = 35
Rottie S(6) + L(11) = 6
dogncatluvr R(3) + G(2) = 5

The letters you have left to choose from:
B C D F J K M N Q V W X Y Z