I agree with jenluckenbach.
Do what your heart says. The orange kitty might be best for you. I had an opportunity to adopt two ferals before I rescued my two boys. I had to tell a dear friend 'no' when she knew I was looking for a copule cats. The socialization and interactivity in our houshold is so important to me, I wanted the freindliest cats possible. They are the center of attention. I can't imagine a kitty under the bed. I'd lose my mind with concern.

Good Luck.