Thanks for the posts guys you're awesome!

So I went to the Dog's Meow today (awesome place and very knowledgeable people, but unfortunately the guy didn't tell me chicken is a huge allergen?) We actually ended up with California Natural Chicken diet. I may end up switching him to the herring diet now that you guys told me I should try the fish. Most of the foods there were all made by Natura, and they didn't have Orijen or Acana (although the guy said the owner is thinking about bringing those in).
I asked about the company MonicanHonda said they sold to. He told me that they are keeping the same building, same employees, same ingredients and sources for those ingredients. He said he understands if people switch for ethical reasons (not sure what that meant?), but nutrition wise it's staying the same. He also recommended Evo (the totally grain free option), but I don't have the money right now to feed that... I may end up switching eventually.

Although it's not COMPLETELY grain free, I'm really hoping that this will do. He said he recommended it for allergens. My dogs definitely have goopy eyes, and Sam has the itches and greasy fur just days after his baths! I'm hoping this will change. I also got some samples for Springen.

There was also this beagle mix there (possibly with lab?), that the owner is fostering and is up for adoption. I wanted to take him home sooooo bad!! Unfortunately my mom won't agree to another dog hehe, oh well, starting college in the fall I won't have much time for another one anyway!

EDIT: Oh and I looked today and realized Sam isn't fed Science Diet, it is Hill's Perscription Diet z/d (Don't know what I was thinking..) but I think it's about the same thing? Anyways, I looked and on the bag and on Hill's it says to feed a 20 pound dog 2 1/4 cups a day.... and on California Natural it says 1.5 cups!! BIG difference!