There are 4 "I"s and 5 "T"s

E-e-y -oy --o--d -a-e t-o t-i---: a do-, a-d a -ot-e- -i--i-- to -et -i- -a-e o-e."

(-) A-o-y-o--

Score:
Logan, D & O - 21 points
Fuzzy317, A & Y & I - 23 points
Karen, E & T- 19 points

The letters you have left to choose from:
B C F G H J K L M N P Q R S U V W X Z