Okay then, as long as I'm hosting the puzzle, the letter Y is a consonant.

There are 9 "O"s

E-e-y -oy --o--d -a-e --o ------: a do-, a-d a -o--e- ------- -o -e- --- -a-e o-e."

(-) A-o-y-o--

Score:
Logan, D & O - 21 points
Fuzzy317, A & Y - 15 points
Karen, E - 14 points

The letters you have left to choose from:
B C F G H I J K L M N P Q R S T U V W X Z