Do you think the Italian studen Amanda Knox got a fair trial???

[Alysser]

I'm on the fence with this one. Should the United State intervene if there's going to be a HUGE issue and future problems wth Italy over it? Sometimes you have to think of the masses before the one. I am not really sure where I stand with the case but I am just thinking logically for the future. Now, I am not saying there's going to be a war over this issue, but hey, ya never know.It's not like little thinks haven't sparked wars in the past. Like I said. think of the masses before the one. Yes, I'm aware she's an American citizen but if she murdered someone she should get what she deserves. A problem with Italy over one person seems a bit silly to me, and it most certainly is not needed, especially at this moment.

I am aware some people will think it is about our 'image' as a nation and it shows we allow other countries to walk all over us, but I still stand on the side of "the needs of the many outweigh the needs of the one", and now my Star Trek nerdiness is kicking in. Do I think we should make a HUGE deal over this? No. Do I think we should possibly do a little something? Maybe. I really need to research this case more though.

[momcat]

I don't think she got a fair trial. When all this first started I remember there were questions about the investigation and evidence being tainted. Sadly, we may never know what really happened.

[Marigold2]

I just don't think she is innocent. Not sure to what extent she was involved but I do believe she was in the apartment when the girl was murdered.
As far as a fair trial when in Italy.................