Tubby
http://catoftheday.com/archive/2002/March/29.html

Peanut
http://catoftheday.com/archive/2002/May/02.html

I was quite active at the time they were both chosen. We've had CJ for almost 5 years now, and I have yet to nominate him. Needless to say, if CJ hasn't been nominated yet, Robin hasn't either.....BAD meowmy!