Here's the puzzle:

"Ho- ni-e it is to thin- that -e-ine -reams, -i-e o-r o-n, are -ainte- -ith
-reati-e br-sh stro-es -rom time -o time. -erha-s m- -ats an- I e-en share
the same -ream: a -or-- -here a-- -ittens are -ante- an- -o-e-, an- -here
e-er- -at has a sa-e, -arm --a-e to s-ee- ... an- to -ream."

Bar-ara - -iamon-

letters remaining:
CDFGJKLPQUVWXYZ


Grace, 34 e's, 14 i's, 19 r's, 29 a's, 2 b's - 175 points
Moesha, 12 o's, 13 s's - 37 points
Karen, 19 t's - 19 points
Killearn Kitties - 13 n's - 13 points
Randi - 11 h's - 11 points
Happy Labs - 10 m's - 10 points