Grace - 3 a's, 2 L's - 8 points

Randi - 9 e's - 18 points

Lvpets2002 - 3 c's, 2 d's, 1 i - 7 points

Karen 8 - o's - 16 points

Here’s the puzzle:

-o- --o- -o-- -e--i-- olde- --e- --e ca-dle- co-- -o-e --a- --e ca-e.
-o- -o-e

note...was one letter short in the fourth word...sorry I suck!

Letters to guess:
BFGHJKMNOPQRSTUVWXYZ