American Idol Season 8 ----SPOILERS INSIDE-----

[Karen]

I was disappointed with Lil's version of The Rose, she was off-pitch in many noticeable places. I think she cut out many of the more effective lyrics, too - I know the song well. I think she's kind of lost her way, trying to please the judges that she's lost her own personality. I hope she refinds herself along the way.

[beeniesmom]

Adam was so very entertaining. He's too good to be on Idol.
He should be selling out concert venues.

Danny would have been great if he hadn't started so low pitched.
I just love his voice. Whew... dreamy....

Anoop was really good. His voice is so sweet.
With the right songs, he does really well.

Allison was ok for me.
I just wish she would ennunciate the words of the songs more instead of breathing them.
In the end I think that will hurt her.

Probably Lil, Matt & whatshisname (crooked lips when he sings) are in the bottom three.