American Idol Season 8 ----SPOILERS INSIDE-----

[beeniesmom]

I think Michael, Scott and Lil should be in the bottom 3.
I don't care for Megan but she really is unique. I wouldn't mind seeing her for another week or so.
They all seemd to have a little bit of a hard time this week.

My top three are Adam, Danny and Matt. It's a battle of the boys!!!

The judges are so strange.... I agree Paula gets wierder every episode.
Simon is Simon. He's actually a great part of the show. He's really is good at his job. I always agree with what he has to say even if it comes out as harsh. The essence of what he has to say is usually on target.

[Daisy and Delilah]

I have to agree that Simon is pretty much on target with everything he says. His words are harsh but he speaks the truth alot better than I can say it.

I'm on a campaign to get rid of Paula forever!! She's not only out of it but now she's wayyyy too silly with these antics. Paula and Simon are playing while Randy and Kara are completely professional. Bring back the respect P and S!!!

[prechrswife]

Our DVR messed up, so I only got to see the last 50 minutes or so of last night's show (from Lil through the end). Sounds like I got to see most of the best ones, though. I really liked Adam's performance.

[Taz_Zoee]

I thought Michael, Scott, Matt and Lil weren't very good, IMO. I really like Megan but her song last night was HORRIBLE. She sounded better last week when she was sick. Her voice kept cracking last night. Maybe it was from just getting over being sick.

Adam was good, but I would have liked to hear him sing some lower notes. I really like it when he shows his broad range in his voice. Last night it was all so high pitched.


I really liked Danny and Allison. They are my top boy/girl favorites.

[Nomilynn]

Now that ANTM is on, I'm not watching the performances, just the boot-off episodes. I am finding this year REALLY boring. I think AI might be at the end of it's road for me!!

[Daisy and Delilah]

I just wrote an email to the Idol people on the link on their website.

There are some people posting about Paula and Simon on their forums. Most of it is positive reaction. There are some complaints. I don't mind a little goofing off but they've exceeded "a little".

This is supposed to be such a serious competition to those kids, I think they deserve more respect. Maybe they like the humor to settle their nerves? I don't know. I just can't see the judges asking for perfection when two of them are acting so silly.

I have a sense of humor but I don't like disrespect. There are boundaries. It was bad enough with Paula acting wasted most of the time. Simon joining her is really adding too much to setting a proper mood. Randy and Kara are so professional. They're probably getting tired of P and S too.

[snowbelle15]

I agree that Simon and Paula have to stop acting so childish.

I loved Adam. He is my absolute favorite. I also thought Matt and Allison were good too. Megan needs to go home. She really isn't that good.

[Karen]

I thought Michael, Scott, Matt and Lil weren't very good, IMO. I really like Megan but her song last night was HORRIBLE. She sounded better last week when she was sick. Her voice kept cracking last night. Maybe it was from just getting over being sick.

Adam was good, but I would have liked to hear him sing some lower notes. I really like it when he shows his broad range in his voice. Last night it was all so high pitched.


I really liked Danny and Allison. They are my top boy/girl favorites.

I thought Megan was bad last week, but was awful this week. She barely sounded like she could hold a tune, and was too concerned with smiling and looking pretty.

I loved Adam, and several of the others. I expected better of Lil, as did everyone else, but I really hope Megan gets sent home this week.

[Daisy and Delilah]

Megan is an incredibly beautiful girl. She showed singing ability at one time. What has happened to her? Last night was embarrassing.

No matter when she goes, somebody has already seen her and she's got a career in her future. I don't know what it will be but she can bet her life will change. She seemed so confident last night that her fans would bring her through. I hope not. It's too painful to watch. She seems to be a fairly likeable girl though.

[beeniesmom]

I agree.... but I still think Michael, Scott or Lil are getting the boot tonight. Probably Michael.

[Daisy and Delilah]

Goodbye Michael. He seemed to take it well. I hope he gets something going for himself from this. I guess he gets to tour with them.

I was a little surprised to see Matt in the bottom three. I really thought he was going. I like him alot but I don't know if he can survive future shows that are out of his style.

Why is Megan still there?