My cats give this an A+

[Queen of Poop]

I got mice similar to that for the kittens. Cali proceeded to chew the noses off and ruin them. Bad girl!!

[Taz_Zoee]

We sell those mice in the boutique at the shelter.
It's difficult to have cat toys with a puppy around. But as it was stated in a dog thread a while back there is a brand out there that is actually pretty tough. It is called Fat Cat. And I received a Fat Cat cat toy in a box of goodies from Katie back when I first got Paizly. She likes to play with this and Taggart can't chew it up. She also likes an old fabric mouse that Taggart hasn't eaten yet. In fact, this morning she woke Bruce up playing with it on the bed. She tosses it around and pounces on it. LOL

[krazyaboutkatz]

My cats also love this kind of mice. Pearl and Ziggy love the small furry mice with the feather tails or regular tails which I cut off so they won't eat them. Sky loves the larger mice that have catnip in them. Most of my cats also love the round plastic tube with the ball inside which I call the kitty roulette wheel. They love to play with boxes and Peal has a thing for straws too.

[catmandu]

Well thier favorite are the Animal Welfare Association Big Mice, but they like the Friendship Cat Nip Fish Via Guatemala , and anything thats small and they can roll around. from Aunt Helene and Aunt Pat
And once in a while the Crinkle Toys come about and the Fur Tailed Soccer Ball that Randi set years ago.There are so many Toys sent over the years, and the ones that are not used here co to the Cats of The Animal Welfare so they can have fun while waiting for thier Furr Ever Homes.

[Barbara]

Oh- feather mousies! That's a toy we like very much here Gives you that natural killing feeling

[Freedom]

Oh yeah, I got those a few times, the feathers are a HUGE hit! I have to keep watch, the cats seem to think they are supposed to EAT them and the feathers are a choking hazard; at least to one of mine who started gagging and hacking.

Cuddles LOVE those, so I try to always have one for her. She "talks" to it, bats it around, scolds it for going the wrong way, SO funny!

[bowlkat]

All the members of our Pride have a nasty habit of chewing feathers off things and trying to eat them, and especially with red feathers, the color isn't color-fast so we get miserable stains all over everything from them- so feathers have been banned. However, there are small (about 1-1/2" square) sewn catnip pillows we get from CattyShack (on-line store- Google it!), which are inexpensive and packed with some of the most POWERFUL catnip I've ever encountered-- our cats get thoroughly gooned-up on the stuff and play with the pillows by the hour! They bat them around, fetch them, chase them, chew them up, carry them around like prey-- and they DON'T leach out dyes or stain anything or shed parts that cats can swallow or choke on-- they're the BEST........