My little man has his favorite toys: Mr. Bunny (we had to sew his body back together), Mr. Mouse (he was losing his head and I had to sew that back), Blue Fuzzy Ball (I actually haven't had to sew anything on this yet).

Fiona loves her leash, even though she doesn't walk with it but she likes dragging it around the house.

And the rest, I'd say anytype of cat nip toys but those are my 2 that really love certain toys only.